# Honest Amish Classic vs Scotch Porter

> Honest Amish Classic Beard Balm and Scotch Porter Beard Balm side by side. Honest Amish Classic Beard Balm has 4 balms on sale in 3 scent families, in 2 oz and 4 oz, priced $11.58 to $22.77 ($5.69 to $7.43 per ounce). Scotch Porter Beard Balm has 2 balms on sale in 1 scent family, in 1 oz and 3 oz. Best value per ounce: Honest Amish Classic Beard Balm Original 4 oz at $5.69 against Scotch Porter Beard Balm Original 3 oz at $6.00.

| | [Honest Amish Classic Beard Balm](https://beardgrid.com/lines/honest-amish-classic-beard-balm/) | [Scotch Porter Beard Balm](https://beardgrid.com/lines/scotch-porter-beard-balm/) |
|---|---|---|
| Launched | — | about 2015 |
| Balms on sale | 4 | 2 |
| Scent families | Woodsy (2), Smoke & Tobacco (1), Unscented (1) | Spiced (2) |
| Sizes | 2 oz, 4 oz | 1 oz, 3 oz |
| Price range | $11.58 – $22.77 | $18.00 – $18.00 |
| Per ounce | $5.69 – $7.43 | $6.00 – $6.00 |
| Hold, where stated | none stated | none stated |
| Key ingredients | apricot kernel oil, argan oil, avocado oil, beeswax, candelilla wax | aloe vera, biotin, castor oil, coconut oil, jojoba oil |
| Made in | USA | not stated |
| Where sold | Honest Amish, Pasteur Pharmacy, Amazon | Scotch Porter |

## Questions

**Which is cheaper per ounce, Honest Amish Classic Beard Balm or Scotch Porter Beard Balm?**
On the prices we have (as of October 5, 2026), the best value in Honest Amish Classic Beard Balm is the [Honest Amish Classic Beard Balm Original 4 oz](https://beardgrid.com/products/honest-amish-classic-beard-balm-original-4oz/) at $5.69/oz and the best value in Scotch Porter Beard Balm is the [Scotch Porter Beard Balm Original 3 oz](https://beardgrid.com/products/scotch-porter-beard-balm-original-3oz/) at $6.00/oz. Per ounce it can differ a lot from the price of the tin, because the sizes differ. Prices are re-checked weekly.

**Which is cheaper, Honest Amish Classic Beard Balm or Scotch Porter Beard Balm?**
The cheapest tin of Honest Amish Classic Beard Balm is the [Honest Amish Classic Beard Balm Original 2 oz](https://beardgrid.com/products/honest-amish-classic-beard-balm-original-2oz/) at $11.58; the cheapest of Scotch Porter Beard Balm is the [Scotch Porter Beard Balm Original 3 oz](https://beardgrid.com/products/scotch-porter-beard-balm-original-3oz/) at $18.00 (as of October 5, 2026).

**Which has more scents, Honest Amish Classic Beard Balm or Scotch Porter Beard Balm?**
Honest Amish Classic Beard Balm: 4 balms on sale across 3 scent families. Scotch Porter Beard Balm: 2 across 1.

**What sizes do Honest Amish Classic Beard Balm and Scotch Porter Beard Balm come in?**
Honest Amish Classic Beard Balm comes in 2 oz and 4 oz; Scotch Porter Beard Balm comes in 1 oz and 3 oz.

**How do the ingredients of Honest Amish Classic Beard Balm and Scotch Porter Beard Balm differ?**
The ingredients Honest Amish Classic Beard Balm names most often are apricot kernel oil, argan oil, avocado oil, beeswax and candelilla wax; for Scotch Porter Beard Balm: aloe vera, biotin, castor oil, coconut oil and jojoba oil. Each product page shows the brand's own list where it publishes one.

Full product lists with specs and sources: [Honest Amish Classic Beard Balm](https://beardgrid.com/lines/honest-amish-classic-beard-balm/index.md), [Scotch Porter Beard Balm](https://beardgrid.com/lines/scotch-porter-beard-balm/index.md). Page: https://beardgrid.com/vs/honest-amish-vs-scotch-porter/

---
BeardBalms lists beard balms from every brand side by side, with a source for every spec. [How we compare](https://beardgrid.com/how-we-compare/). Data as of 2026-10-05.