Honest Amish vs other beard balm brands
Honest Amish against the other 77 beard balm brands, side by side: its 7 balms (2 oz and 4 oz) at a median $5.88 an ounce, against $9.00 across everyone else, with each brand's sizes, price per ounce, hold and ingredients.
Honest Amish against the rest of the catalogue
| Fact | 
Honest Amish |
Every other brand |
|---|---|---|
| Balms on sale | 7 | 619 from 77 brands |
| Scent families | Woodsy (2), Citrus (2), Smoke & Tobacco (1), Unscented (2) | Woodsy (129), Sweet & Gourmand (93), Citrus (96), Smoke & Tobacco (69), Fresh & Cool (61), Spiced (59), Unscented (34), Herbal & Earthy (41), Other (37) |
| Sizes | 2 oz, 4 oz | 1 oz, 1.3 oz, 1.5 oz, 1.6 oz, 1.7 oz, 1.76 oz, 2 oz, 2.1 oz, 3 oz, 3.38 oz, 3.4 oz, 3.6 oz, 4 oz, 4.2 oz |
| Price of a tin | $11.58 – $22.77cheapest: Honest Amish Classic Beard Balm Original 2 oz | $5.19 – $39.00cheapest: Clubman Pinaud Beard Balm 2 oz |
| Per ounce, median | $5.88across 7 balms with a price and a size | $9.00across 591 balms with a price and a size |
| Per ounce, range | $5.69 – $7.43best value: Honest Amish Classic Beard Balm Original 4 oz | $2.20 – $17.95best value: NishMan Beard & Moustache Styling Balm 3.4 oz |
| Hold, where stated | none stated | Light (88), Medium (112) |
| Key ingredients | apricot kernel oil, argan oil, avocado oil, beeswax, candelilla wax | beeswax, jojoba oil, shea butter, argan oil, coconut oil |
| Vegan | none stated | 35 of 619 per the brand |
| Made in | USA | United Kingdom, USA, Ireland |
The comparisons people search for
Search suggestions for Honest Amish most often name these other brands. Each page lines the two ranges up by scent family and size.
Honest Amish against each brand
Each row is one other brand's range on sale. Median per oz is the middle of the per-ounce prices of its balms that have both a price and a size, and Against Honest Amish is that median minus Honest Amish's ($5.88): a minus sign means the brand costs less per ounce at the median. A median over one or two balms rests on very few prices, so read the balm count beside it. Column headers sort.
| Brand | Balms | Sizes (oz) | Median per oz | Against Honest Amish | Hold, where stated | Vegan | Made in |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
18.21 Man Made |
2 | 2 | $13.00 | +$7.12 | Light (2) | none stated | not stated |
American Crew |
1 | 2.1 | $9.04 | +$3.16 | none stated | none stated | not stated |
Artius Man |
22 | 2 | $9.47$9.47 to $11.97 | +$3.59 | Light (4), Medium (4) | none stated | USA |
Avocado Beard Co |
6 | 2 | $11.00 | +$5.12 | none stated | none stated | not stated |
| Badass Beard Care | 14 | 2 | $9.99 | +$4.11 | Light (14) | none stated | USA |
| Badger | 1 | 2 | $8.49 | +$2.61 | none stated | none stated | USA |
| Beard Octane | 13 | 2 | $9.99$8.99 to $9.99 | +$4.11 | Medium (13) | none stated | USA |
BeardbrandHead to head |
5 | 4.2 | $8.57$5.95 to $9.29 | +$2.69 | none stated | none stated | not stated |
Bearded Coast |
11 | 2 | $11.99 | +$6.11 | none stated | 11 of 11 | USA |
Bearded Oregon |
13 | 2 | $9.00 | +$3.12 | none stated | none stated | not stated |
| Beaumont Grooming Co. | 1 | 3.6 | $6.11 | +$0.23 | none stated | none stated | not stated |
| Billy Jealousy | 3 | 2 | $9.00 | +$3.12 | Light (3) | none stated | not stated |
BLCK |
1 | 2 | $12.50 | +$6.62 | none stated | 1 of 1 | not stated |
Blind Barber |
1 | 1.5 | $13.33 | +$7.45 | none stated | none stated | not stated |
Bossman |
7 | 2 | $8.97 | +$3.09 | none stated | none stated | not stated |
| Brigid Trading Company | 5 | 1.5, 3 | $7.33$6.67 to $8.00 | +$1.46 | none stated | none stated | USA |
| Brooklyn Grooming | 10 | 1, 2 | $14.00$6.50 to $15.00 | +$8.12 | none stated | none stated | not stated |
Burt's Bees |
1 | 3 | $3.33 | −$2.55 | none stated | none stated | USA |
Captain Fawcett |
6 | 2 | $17.62$17.50 to $17.75 | +$11.75 | none stated | none stated | United Kingdom |
| Chattanooga Beard Co. | 11 | 2 | $10.00 | +$4.12 | Light (8) | none stated | not stated |
| Cimarron Creek Essentials | 5 | 2 | $8.47 | +$2.59 | none stated | none stated | USA |
| Clubman Pinaud | 1 | 2 | $2.60 | −$3.28 | none stated | none stated | not stated |
Cremo |
1 | 2 | $6.00 | +$0.12 | none stated | none stated | not stated |
Dalysmooth |
3 | 4 | $9.50 | +$3.62 | Light (3) | none stated | USA |
| Dapper Dan | 1 | 1.7 | $10.59 | +$4.71 | none stated | none stated | not stated |
Dr. K Soap Company |
4 | 1.7 | $11.18 | +$5.30 | none stated | none stated | Ireland |
| Dr. Watson's | 1 | 2 | $8.50 | +$2.62 | none stated | none stated | not stated |
| Dubs Was Here | 3 | 2 | $8.00 | +$2.12 | Light (3) | none stated | USA |
Duke Cannon |
2 | 1.6 | $6.88 | +$1.00 | none stated | none stated | not stated |
EpiLynx |
1 | 2 | $9.50 | +$3.62 | none stated | 1 of 1 | not stated |
Every Man JackHead to head |
1 | 2 | $6.00 | +$0.12 | Medium (1) | none stated | not stated |
| Fable Beard Co | 55 | 2 | $11.99 | +$6.11 | none stated | none stated | USA |
Fresh Beards |
14 | 2 | $8.49 | +$2.61 | Medium (6) | none stated | USA |
Grave Before ShaveHead to head |
29 | 2, 4 | $7.00$5.00 to $8.99 | +$1.12 | none stated | none stated | not stated |
Handsome & Debonair |
18 | 2 | $13.24$12.49 to $13.99 | +$7.36 | Light (3) | 11 of 18 | not stated |
| Honor Initiative | 8 | 1.7 | $14.71$11.18 to $14.71 | +$8.83 | Medium (8) | none stated | USA |
| Jimbob's Grizzly Beard Care | 10 | 2 | $10.99$9.99 to $10.99 | +$5.11 | Medium (10) | none stated | not stated |
| King C. Gillette | 1 | 3.38 | $5.47 | −$0.41 | none stated | none stated | not stated |
| Lather and More | 2 | 4 | $7.50 | +$1.62 | Medium (1) | 1 of 2 | USA |
| Long Rifle Soap Co. | 3 | 3 | $6.67 | +$0.79 | Light (3) | none stated | not stated |
Mad Viking Beard Co |
12 | 2 | $11.00 | +$5.12 | Medium (12) | none stated | not stated |
Manscaped |
1 | 2 | $7.50 | +$1.62 | none stated | none stated | not stated |
Mission Beard |
4 | 1.7 | $13.53 | +$7.65 | none stated | none stated | not stated |
Modern Viking Beard Co. |
28 | 2, 4 | $7.38$6.75 to $8.00 | +$1.50 | none stated | none stated | USA |
Mountaineer Brand |
8 | 2 | $8.49 | +$2.61 | none stated | none stated | USA |
| NishMan | 1 | 3.4 | $2.20 | −$3.68 | Light (1) | none stated | not stated |
| O'Douds | 2 | 2 | $10.00 | +$4.12 | Light (1), Medium (1) | none stated | not stated |
| Plant Therapy | 1 | 1.7 | $9.99 | +$4.11 | none stated | none stated | not stated |
| Razor MD | 3 | 2 | $10.50 | +$4.62 | none stated | none stated | USA |
Reuzel |
2 | 1, 1.3 | $14.34$10.73 to $17.95 | +$8.46 | none stated | none stated | not stated |
Rocky Mountain Barber Co |
4 | 2 | $7.00 | +$1.12 | none stated | none stated | not stated |
| Roosevelt Supply Co. | 3 | 2 | $10.00 | +$4.12 | none stated | none stated | not stated |
Royal Beardsmen |
15 | 2 | $7.97 | +$2.09 | none stated | none stated | not stated |
Rugged History Beard Co. |
48 | 2 | $8.00 | +$2.12 | Medium (48) | none stated | USA |
Samson's Haircare |
2 | 2 | $7.50 | +$1.62 | none stated | none stated | USA |
| Scotch PorterHead to head | 2 | 1, 3 | $6.00 | +$0.12 | none stated | none stated | not stated |
Seven PotionsHead to head |
2 | 2 | $11.49 | +$5.61 | none stated | none stated | United Kingdom |
| SheaMoisture | 1 | 4 | $2.46 | −$3.42 | none stated | none stated | USA |
Smooth Viking |
1 | 2 | $6.75 | +$0.87 | none stated | 1 of 1 | USA |
Soaplicity |
6 | 1.3 | $11.50 | +$5.62 | none stated | none stated | USA |
| Southern Fades | 18 | 2 | $13.24$12.49 to $13.99 | +$7.36 | none stated | 9 of 18 | not stated |
Stache Salt |
6 | 2 | $8.00$8.00 to $9.00 | +$2.12 | Light (4), Medium (1) | none stated | not stated |
Stirling Soap Co. |
41 | 2 | $6.97$4.50 to $6.97 | +$1.09 | none stated | none stated | USA |
Suavecito |
2 | 2 | $6.50$6.00 to $7.00 | +$0.62 | none stated | none stated | USA |
| Taconic Shave | 2 | 2 | $7.50 | +$1.62 | none stated | none stated | USA |
Texas Beard Company |
22 | 2, 4 | $9.37$8.75 to $9.99 | +$3.49 | none stated | none stated | USA |
| The Beard Struggle | 9 | 1.76 | $16.48$13.07 to $16.48 | +$10.60 | none stated | none stated | not stated |
| The Bearded Brotherhood | 9 | 2 | $13.00$11.00 to $13.00 | +$7.12 | none stated | none stated | not stated |
The Bearded Grenade |
23 | 4 | $6.50 | +$0.62 | Light (23) | none stated | USA |
| The Big Foot Refinery | 1 | 2 | $8.50 | +$2.62 | none stated | none stated | not stated |
| Uppercut Deluxe | 1 | 3.38 | $5.62 | −$0.26 | none stated | none stated | not stated |
Viking RevolutionHead to head |
12 | 2 | $5.00 | −$0.88 | none stated | none stated | not stated |
Warlord Beard Oil |
4 | 2 | $12.00 | +$6.12 | Medium (3) | none stated | USA |
Weatherbeard Supply |
9 | 2 | $12.50 | +$6.62 | Medium (4) | none stated | not stated |
| Woody's | 1 | 2 | $3.25 | −$2.63 | none stated | none stated | not stated |
ZEUS |
3 | 2 | $12.00 | +$6.12 | Light (3) | none stated | USA |
| Zingari Man | 13 | 1.5 | $10.63$10.63 to $11.30 | +$4.75 | Light (13) | none stated | USA |
Questions
Is Honest Amish cheaper per ounce than other beard balms?
Honest Amish's median price per ounce is $5.88 across its 7 balms with a price and a size; across every other brand it is $9.00 (591 balms). Of the 77 other brands with such a balm, 8 have a lower median than Honest Amish and 69 a higher one (prices as of October 5, 2026, re-checked weekly). A median over one or two balms rests on very few prices, so read the balm counts in the table.
What sizes does Honest Amish come in, compared with other brands?
Honest Amish comes in 2 oz and 4 oz. Of the 616 balms on sale that state a size, 470 are 2 oz; size tiers and the size of every balm are on each product page.
Which brands do people compare Honest Amish with?
Search suggestions for Honest Amish most often name the other brand in these comparisons: Grave Before Shave vs Honest Amish Classic, Honest Amish Classic vs Viking Revolution, Honest Amish Classic vs Scotch Porter and Honest Amish Classic vs Seven Potions. Each one lines the two ranges up by scent family, size, price per ounce and hold.
Does Honest Amish say how strong its hold is?
Honest Amish names no hold level for any of its 7 balms. Across the catalogue, 200 of 626 balms on sale have a hold their brand names; a blank means the brand states none, not that the balm has none.
Is Honest Amish vegan?
Honest Amish calls 0 of its 7 balms vegan; across the catalogue 35 of 626 balms on sale are called vegan by their brand. Most balms are not: beeswax, lanolin and tallow are animal products.
Where is Honest Amish made?
Honest Amish says its balms are made in USA; each product page shows the sentence it was read from.
Answered from the catalogue data, as of October 5, 2026. How we compare.