Honest Amish Classic vs Scotch Porter
Honest Amish Classic Beard Balm and Scotch Porter Beard Balm side by side. Honest Amish Classic Beard Balm has 4 balms on sale in 3 scent families, in 2 oz and 4 oz, priced $11.58 to $22.77 ($5.69 to $7.43 per ounce). Scotch Porter Beard Balm has 2 balms on sale in 1 scent family, in 1 oz and 3 oz. Best value per ounce: Honest Amish Classic Beard Balm Original 4 oz at $5.69 against Scotch Porter Beard Balm Original 3 oz at $6.00.
At a glance
| Fact | 
Honest Amish Classic Beard Balm |
Scotch Porter Beard Balm |
|---|---|---|
| Launched | — | ~2015 |
| Balms on sale | 4 | 2 |
| Scent families | Woodsy (2), Smoke & Tobacco (1), Unscented (1) | Spiced (2) |
| Sizes | 2 oz, 4 oz | 1 oz, 3 oz |
| Price range | $11.58 – $22.77cheapest: Original 2 oz | $18.00cheapest: Original 3 oz |
| Per ounce | $5.69 – $7.43best value: Original 4 oz | $6.00best value: Original 3 oz |
| Hold, where stated | none stated | none stated |
| Key ingredients | apricot kernel oil, argan oil, avocado oil, beeswax, candelilla wax | aloe vera, biotin, castor oil, coconut oil, jojoba oil |
| Vegan | none stated | none stated |
| Made in | USA | not stated |
| Where sold | Honest Amish, Pasteur Pharmacy, Amazon and more | Scotch Porter |
Only one of them makes
- Honest Amish Classic Beard Balm only: woodsy, smoke & tobacco, unscented scents.
- Scotch Porter Beard Balm only: spiced scents.
Put their best-value balms side by side
Questions
Which is cheaper per ounce, Honest Amish Classic Beard Balm or Scotch Porter Beard Balm?
On the prices we have (as of October 5, 2026), the best value in Honest Amish Classic Beard Balm is the Honest Amish Classic Beard Balm Original 4 oz at $5.69/oz and the best value in Scotch Porter Beard Balm is the Scotch Porter Beard Balm Original 3 oz at $6.00/oz. Per ounce it can differ a lot from the price of the tin, because the sizes differ. Prices are re-checked weekly.
Which is cheaper, Honest Amish Classic Beard Balm or Scotch Porter Beard Balm?
The cheapest tin of Honest Amish Classic Beard Balm is the Honest Amish Classic Beard Balm Original 2 oz at $11.58; the cheapest of Scotch Porter Beard Balm is the Scotch Porter Beard Balm Original 3 oz at $18.00 (as of October 5, 2026).
Which has more scents, Honest Amish Classic Beard Balm or Scotch Porter Beard Balm?
Honest Amish Classic Beard Balm: 4 balms on sale across 3 scent families. Scotch Porter Beard Balm: 2 across 1.
What sizes do Honest Amish Classic Beard Balm and Scotch Porter Beard Balm come in?
Honest Amish Classic Beard Balm comes in 2 oz and 4 oz; Scotch Porter Beard Balm comes in 1 oz and 3 oz.
How do the ingredients of Honest Amish Classic Beard Balm and Scotch Porter Beard Balm differ?
The ingredients Honest Amish Classic Beard Balm names most often are apricot kernel oil, argan oil, avocado oil, beeswax and candelilla wax; for Scotch Porter Beard Balm: aloe vera, biotin, castor oil, coconut oil and jojoba oil. Each product page shows the brand's own list where it publishes one.
Answered from the catalogue data, as of October 5, 2026. How we compare.